Indoctrination Another sign of religious brainwashing is losing your sense of identity and individuality. This could be in the form of: What youre allowed to say (certain topics may be off-limits) From my experience, those who are healthily religious manage to find a balance between faith and personal individuality. The smoke generated by the battle over faith schools has obscured a far more fundamental dispute that between liberals and authoritarians. If, as an authoritarian, you want children to believe what you tell them, it is unwise to let them mix with unbelievers. This is a hard one. Later, two studies of the Korean War defections by Robert Lifton (1961) and Edgar Schein (1961) concluded that brainwashing had only a transient effect when used onprisoners of war(POWs). So you cant be a faithful Christian (or Jew) and not teachthe faith to your children. Komendy CS GO. When sufficient number of people come together, that can make an impact on the society concerned to change as happened throughout the ages. Dr.J. Gordon Melton, Distinguished Professor of American Religion, Baylor University, and Founder of Institute for the Study of American Religion, writes: Other leading experts in the field share Dr.Meltons view. For, if a person was not programmed through coercive techniques, there was no reason to use such techniques to deprogram them. Later, APA Division 36 (then Psychologists interested in Religion Issues, later Psychology of Religion) in its 1990 annual convention approved the following resolution: The Executive Committee of the Division of Psychologists Interested in Religious Issues supports the conclusion that, at this time, there is no consensus that sufficient psychological research exists to scientifically equate undue non-physical persuasion (otherwise known as coercive persuasion, mind control, or brainwashing) with techniques of influence as typically practiced by one or more religious groups. 2. Brainwashing - Wikipedia A political or religious authoritarian may remove books from libraries and cancel talks (I have had mine cancelled) on the grounds that they will only confuse children. The encyclical opens this way: Faith and reason are like two wings on which the human spirit rises to the contemplation of truth; and God has placed in the human heart a desire to know the truthin a word, to know himselfso that, by knowing and loving God, men and women may also come to the fullness of truth about themselves (cf. So what other religions do is no concern of ours, and we dont have to defend them in the same way that Per Mertesacker doesnt have to pick up a man when Chelsea concede a corner (For non-football fans or Americans, Mertesacker plays for Arsenalwhich is a football team). But lets make sure they are liberal faith schools. Is church brainwashing? : r/religion - Reddit What this means is that you dont feel like you have an identity anymore. It is based off of Dr. Robert Jay Liftons Eight-Point Model of Thought Reform and borrows from several other authorities on the topic of religious mind-control. I see people look at indoctrination as a Rather, many of them behaved as though they did in order to avoid the plausible threat of extreme physical abuse. The changing of a persons behavior through coercive persuasion is possible, but it is not necessarily brainwashing. Authoritarians are far less enthusiastic. It isnt the agreement with a statement about how the world is. In September 1950, theMiami Daily Newspublished an article by Edward Hunter (1902-1978) entitled Brain-Washing Tactics Force Chinese into Ranks of Communist Party. It contained the first printed use of the English-language term brainwashing, which quickly became a stock phrase inCold Warheadlines. I am not sure if this is correct or not. Maybe youhavent noticed this, but man is the only animal that has this yearning to know the truth about God, the universe, and himself. Extensive research proved inconclusive, and although the term continues in popular parlance, brainwashing remains more a fiction than a reality. meaning - Indoctrination vs brainwashing - English In the 1960s, after coming into contact with new religious movements (NRMs), popularly referred to as cults, young people suddenly adoptedfaiths,beliefs, and behavior that differed markedly from their previous lifestyles and seemed at variance with their upbringings. Parabolic, suborbital and ballistic trajectories all follow elliptic paths. Brainwashing Theories: the Myth and WebChanging or replacing an individuals view points, actions etc through coercive, manipulative means = brainwashing One is replacing past thoughts or behaviours one is instilling someone elses viewpoints before an individual is mature enough to make up their own mind or make an educated decision. Conway and Siegelman (1978) described sudden, drastic alterations ofpersonalityin people who joined NRMs. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Dont live in guilt or shame for what others have done to you. Brainwashing someone through religion takes careful planning no matter how strong you are, even the best of us can be manipulated without realizing it. mind control - brainwashing While "coercive persuasion" models do have some heuris LinkedIn and 3rd parties use essential and non-essential cookies to provide, secure, analyze and improve our Services, and to show you relevant ads (including professional and job ads) on and off LinkedIn. A colloquial term, it is How does Scientology view deprogrammers and groups that attempt to force people to denounce their chosen religion? So the accusation of brainwashing in this context was clearly used to defame. Deadly Fasting in Kenya: What We Know So Far Identify Religious Brainwashing: The Dispensing of Existence Brainwashing (Debate Massimo Introvigne (born June 14, 1955 in Rome) is an Italian sociologist of religions. You cannot be brainwashed into love. Rational persuasion involves getting Johnny to apply his own powers of reason and think for himself exactly what Authoritarians dislike. "Brainwashing" is an inherently subjective metaphor that is used as a rationale for persecuting unpopular movements and defining religious converts as nonautonomous zombies who can be coerced for therapeutic purposes. Dick Anthony, a research and forensicpsychologist, claimed that theCIAinvented the brainwashing ideology as apropaganda strategy to undercut communist claims that American prisoners of warin Korean communist camps had voluntarily expressed sympathy forcommunism, and that definitive research demonstrated that collaboration by western POWs had been caused by fear and duress, and not by brainwashing (Anthony 1990). Social scientists concluded that there was no agreement about the existence of a social process attempting coercive influence, nor about the existence of the social outcome that people are influenced against their will. Do you teach them that it might be true that Jesus is their Saviour? Your attempt to sign up by email has failed please try again. Regimented acts of worship have the same effect. According to a Sunday Direct Polls survey, which I find to be the most reliable, as tested in their string of accurate predictions Nothing about the centuries of religious leaders hurting kids? my book The War For Children's Minds. The phrase was a play onx xn( to wash the heart), a phrase found in manyDaoisttemples exhorting the faithful to cleanse their hearts of impure desires before entering. Brainwashing In 1983, the American Psychological Association (APA) askedMargaret Singer, one of the leading proponents of coercive persuasion theories, to chair a task force called DIMPAC to investigate whether brainwashing or coercive persuasion did indeed play a role in recruitment by such movements. But for those at the Authoritarian end of the scale, rational persuasion is not an option. What is Wario dropping at the end of Super Mario Land 2 and why? Amongstatheist adults in America, a full 40% are aged 18-29, and fewer than a quarter are over 50. In Islam we engage the brain with logic and reasoning. Religious brainwashers tend to take a hardline approach to holy commands they dont want liberal interpretations washing down what they preach. Put simply, they dont want their interpretations to be questioned. Conformity is key. Synanon founder Charles Dederich (Photo by Bettmann Archive/Getty Images) Although claiming to be nonviolent, Synanon used tactics such as brainwashing, psychological torture and physical beatings to encourage the submission of its members. But isnt it still the case that bringing up kids to be Christians is brainwashing them, and stops them making up their own minds? Out of work by virtue of these rejections, Singer and an associate responded by filing two lawsuits against the APA and several social scientists for allegedly trying to run them out of business. We don't just accept things, we discuss them within red lines. Nevertheless, it is not far fetched to believe that under extreme circumstances outside forces could influence ones mental state. Skuteczne rzucanie granatw podczas skoku. Singers half-baked theories were soon debunked by the scientific community. Likewise, acclaimed religious scholar Dr.Juha Pentikinen, former Professor and Chair of the Department of the Study of Religions, University of Helsinki, Finland, and the Institute of Social Science, University of Tromso, Norway, and Dr.Jrgen Redhardt, a Doctor of Theology and Diplomate in Psychology, a minister and former Professor of Religious Psychology at the University of Giessen for 26 years, teaching Protestant Theology, conducted and published their own study debunking these theories. Part One: Milieu Control 2.) And it happens by freely inviting Gods spirit into your heart, by welcoming into your life the greatest love in the universe. However, many scholars in the field of new religious movements did not accept Hassans Bite model. This article covers more than techniques used by churches and pastors, but for the purposes of this website, the main focus is on religious indoctrination and brainwashing. This is the completely biased inference that someone who joins a religious group disfavored by whoever is speaking could only have done so as a result of religious brainwashing. The shorthand equation is, I am right. It should be noted that many of these techniques are more subtly used (usually unconsciously) byadvertisers, governments, schools, parents, and peers. Why do some atheists insist they were brainwashed growing up? Its something you have freely chosen to be. The protagonist of the Jason Bourne action movies and novels is an example of brainwashing taken to an extreme I dont believe exists in the real world. Ways to Identify Religious Brainwashing: The Sacred Science Popular speech continues to use the word brainwashed informally and pejoratively to describe persons subjected to intensive influence resulting in the rejection of oldbeliefsand in the acceptance of new ones; or to account for someone who holds strong ideas considered to be implausible and that seem resistant to evidence, common sense, experience, and logic. In other words, such brainwashing is no more than the natural process ofsocialization. Zablocki (1997) and Amitrani (2001), citing APA boards and scholars on the subject, concluded that there has been no unanimous decision of the APA regarding this issue. The negative implications of indoctrination come from the fact that much indoctrination involves presenting the subject only with material and sources which support the views held by the person or organisation doing the indoctrinating, and classifying other material and sources as evil or incompatible with the views being promoted (the attitude of some fundamentalist Christian organisations to The Origin of Species being an example), Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. But perhaps we should call a spade a spade. Rangi CS GO. brainwashing and how to avoid being taken in by mind control. This 2012 Scientology decision by the Ninth Circuit reaffirms that religious brainwashing is an unscientific theory that has no basis in fact, lacks credibility and cannot be accepted as reliable evidence in court. Associate alternatives with negatives: meaninglessness, selfish materialism, amorality, hell, and so on. Nothing about the centuries of religious leaders hurting kids? Your "But below the Who caused you to think like that? While there is not one commonly accepted definition of the word cult most definitions encompass the following characteristics: a group that is critical of or rejects mainstream culture; perceives itself, its leaders and members as elitist and superior; expects conformity to the group's unique pattern of relationships, beliefs, values, and Which was the first Sci-Fi story to predict obnoxious "robo calls"? The nature of brainwashing as it occurred in communist political prisons received widespread attention after the Chinese Communist victory in 1949 and after the Korean and Vietnamese wars. He further asserted that for twenty years, starting in the early 1950s, the CIA and the Defense Department conducted secret research in an attempt to develop practical brainwashing techniques (possibly to counteract the brainwashing efforts of the Chinese), and that the attempt was a failure. For most religious people that are not brainwashed, Benny Gantz and Benjamin Netanyahu. The use of coercive persuasion techniques in China, Brainwashing controversy in new religious movements and cults, Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window), Click to share on Skype (Opens in new window), The alarmist concept of brainwashing functioned as a central theme in the movie. Religious brainwashing is a fantasy; it is nothing but the invention of an uninformed minority used to spread anti-religious sentiments about new religions. It, too, determined to summarily reject Dr.Levines mind control theories as unreliable and to strike his declaration from the record in deciding in favor of the Church and dismissing the specious claims. Those who studied new religious movements recognized that religious groups can have considerable influence over their members, and that such influence may have come about through deception and indoctrination. All I ever saw from them was love of people and stories of Gods goodness. Thus, it is evident that the scientific debate about whether any religion brainwashes its adherents was concluded and relegated to historical commentary as an incident of prejudicial hysteria brought on by a quack psychologist. Your In 1974, the institution sought religious status to avoid legal battles over zoning law violations. Please refer to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have any questions. That hunger can be the cause of a lot of unhappiness, when were lost and confused. All Rights Reserved. In the formal discourses of the Chinese Communist Party, the more clinical-sounding term s xang gi zo (thought reform) came to be preferred. Is there any other way? Well, heres the thing: an institution that churns out generations of non-thinking moralists; a church that demands money; a spiritual leader who coerces or uses emotional mind gamesNONE of this is what Jesus taught or was about. Joe Heschmeyer is an instructor at the Holy Family School of Faith Institutefor the Archdiocese of Kansas City in Kansas, and blogs atShameless Popery. One of the scariest signs of cult brainwashing is that your identity is stripped from you. Accusations that new religious movements, or cults, employed similar techniques to gain and retain members fueled this argument. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? Control environment: Loved ones are cut off from family, no communication. Another alleged technique of religious brainwashing involved love bombing rather thantorture. ) Wszystko, co powiniene o nich wiedzie. baked_in 1 yr. ago You are not good. If you ridicule something and talk of it in terms that you find alien/offensive, you never have to be challenged by it. Varioussocial scientistsattempted to develop theories of this process. Indoctrination is the process of inculcating a person with ideas, attitudes, cognitive strategies or professional methodologies (see doctrine). What Is Brainwashing? - The Spiritual Life (PIRI Executive Committee Adopts Position on Non-Physical Persuasion Winter, 1991, in Amitrano and Di Marzio, 2001). Break down the persons sense of self. Uncertainty. in the TV series Misfits? published by the Center for Studies on New Religions, The Unreliability of Stories and Rumors byApostates. Respected sociologists and experts in religion have also closed the door on this ignorant and archaic view. The first suit was dismissed as having no merit. Some examples include: There seems to be little to no accord among specialists on the existence of brainwashing, although many have theorized thattorture, sleep deprivation, and other such techniques may alter a persons state of mind.