Why does Scrooge advocate the death of the poor? By the end of the story, Scrooge is a changed man, sharing his wealth and generosity with everyone. He may be sitting on a vast pile of money, but Scrooge has little happiness in his sorry, solitary lifein some ways, the Cratchits are better off. Even before Donald Trump took plutocratic arrogance and entitlement to previously unimagined levels, Mitt Romney had mocked the notion that poor people are entitled to health care, to food, to housing, to you-name-it., Likewise, he urged that job creators and business creators get the deference and admiration that he felt they deserved. In A Christmas Carol, Scrooge is dramatically affected by the Cratchit family's poignant scene. "Dickens consciously thought of A Christmas Carol as a message book, which he hoped would deliver what he called a 'sledge-hammer' blow on behalf of ameliorating the suffering of the urban poor," says Dan Shaviro. Analysis. dickens describes him as a "squeezing, wrenching and covetous old sinner. Click here to unlock this and over one million essays. The boy and girl living in the robe of the Ghost of Christmas Present represent what? In this essay I am going to distinguish the personality of Scrooge also show you how he was at the beginning of the novella in the 1st Stave to how he changes at the end in the 5th Stave. Bob Cratchit shows respect to Scrooge even as Scrooge sees Bob as a guy trying to take his money and the small coal fire symbolizes the poor situation. At last, however, he began to think- as you or I would have though at first; "for it is always the person not in the predicament who know what ought to have been done about" This quote is an example of what literary device? Yet the rewards that he gets for his Randian virtues start with mockery, and only escalate from there. Copyright 2000-2023. He's small but sick and on crutches but still very sweet and cheerful. In Dickenss story, Scrooge reforms his life with respect to his fellow man. Latest answer posted December 03, 2020 at 4:13:31 PM. Initially, Scrooge finds the poor and poverty stricken to be an annoyance. He loves his uncle and feels bad for him since he never enjoys the holidays. Scrooge hung his head to hear his own words quoted by the Spirit, and was overcome with penitence and grief. What does the young Scrooge fear too greatly, according to Belle? Scrooge says that poor people who cant support themselves must accept whatever meager scraps they are offered. Why does Scrooge advocate the death of the poor? Scrooge gives which of the following as a reason for not giving to charity? He overcame even the most stubborn of the doubters, Thomas, by appealing to his senses: Reach your finger here, and look at my hands; and reach your hand here, and put it into my side. It also tells us Scrooge was worried about paying What important point does the narrator make in the story's beginning? Either the coach or the players_____ to answer the letter. he sees bob cratchit as ayoung boy, where he's sent off to work for. Latest answer posted December 01, 2021 at 9:27:30 PM. The lesson A Christmas Carol should teach us is not the simplistic view that generosity is better than miserliness, but that wise givingthe ways that Scrooge givesis better than giving badly. It will examine the main character Scrooge, and his Analyzes how dickens wanted to keep the spirit of christmas past mysterious, as he did not know what the future would be like. What can be inferred about Scrooge's home life? The men tell him that some of the poor would rather die. Jean was writing a letter to her aunt to ask her about a ship named Aurelia. Decrease the surplus population" We often fail to realize the extent to which this feel-good story is actually a tale of serial humiliation, as Scrooge sees his old self being disparaged and insulted in scene after scene, culminating with a vision of his own pitiful and lonely future death. He even recommends it to the poor as a means of relieving the surplus population. Scrooge is brought face to face with his own death, his final separation from the world. Why does Marley visit Scrooge. Scrooge also perceives, however, that the family sticks together and experiences love and joy being with each other as they celebrate the holiday. Scrooge can see that Tiny Tim, the youngest child, is lame and sickly, but also can't help but notice that there is no spare money for him to receive the medical treatments that might save his life. middle of paper Analyzes how dickens uses lighter language to show an image of a new and changed character. After the poor law had passed in 1834, life was harsh and workhouses were the only option of being supported but they were horrible and miserable places. Already a member? the moral of the story is that we are not in this world for our own benefit only. Men like Malthus and Scrooge believed that war, famine and pestilence were necessary in order to keep the population down, especially the poor people. Its both a timeless classic with its basics about human interaction, empathy, and resolution- as well as a monicker for generations to come, about what, essentially, is very decent. Charles Dickens meant for A Christmas Carol to serve as a scathing indictment of wealth concentration and neglect of the poor, argues Dan Shaviro. reader. Analyzes how scrooge's character is extremelychanged because of the happenings in chapter 2, 3 and 4. there were three ghosts, one of a positive and active person, the other of an amiss. finally, there's probably the most common one a visit, Scrooge's Change in Attitude in A Christmas Carol. he sees christmas as a time for finding yourself "a year older but not an hour richer.". While Dickens was a young man, he suffered from poverty along with his mother and father. Analyzes how dickens illustrates what is good by demonstrating actions through scrooge that are good, generous and compassionate without an expectation of return. Analyzes how dickens makes the ghost of christmas past seem peaceful and affectionate by saying, "sparkling eye" and "its open hand". They knew he was dead, yet they saw him now alive. Scrooge tells them that he already helps pay for the workhouses and the poor should go there. At the story's start, Scrooge is an antisocial person who avoids interactions with people claiming that they are useless. Explains that scrooge had a bad life but, he fixed it. Why does Scrooge advocate the death of the poor? the spirit does not speak, which adds to its mysteriousness. They are contented and grateful for what little they have, because they have one another and the. Christmas Carol What message do you feel Dickens Conveys to the He also asks about the poor law which shows he doesn't care about the poor and dismisses them as they aren't his responsibility. In stave 1, our impression of Scrooge is that he was an old bitter miser and was malcontent. Besides literal heat, what might symbolize of the tiny coal fire that Cratchit has in the office? The day after Christmas, I went to Metro Stage in Alexandria, Virginia to see A Broadway Christmas Carol, which combined a reasonably accurate version of Dickenss story with show tunes, combining melodies we all know with verses that ranged from silly to very funny. He may be sitting on. Why does Marleys ghost visit Scrooge in the first place? The Spirits show him many things, but what they collectively reveal is Scrooges progressing separation from his fellow man. Scrooges greed is his downfall because he is so consumed with his money that he neglects the people around him, and when all is said and done, the people are what matter most. Moreover, when Scrooge decided to give, it was his decision. The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly of Christian Nationalism, How J. K. Rowling Played, then Lost, the Polarization Game, The FAQs: Anglican Group Calls on Church of Englands Leader to Repent, What to Do When Your Child Is Addicted to Video Games, GAFCON IV: Lessons from a Communion in Birth Pains, Radical Christian Gentleness in an Era of Addictive Outrage. Powered by PressBook Media WordPress theme, Quick Answer: What Happens To Scrooge Stave 5, Quick Answer: How Is Scrooge Presented In Stave 1, Question: How Does Scrooge Change In Stave 1, Quick Answer: How Does Scrooge Change Throughout The Novel, Quick Answer: How Does Scrooge Change Throughout The Play, What Does Scrooge Say About Ignorance And Want, Question: How Does Scrooge Change In A Christmas Carol, Question: How Does The Ghost Of Christmas Present Change Scrooge, How Is Scrooge Presented In A Christmas Carol Essay, Question: Is Hyperterminal Available In Windows 10, Question: How Do I Reinstall Operating System After Replacing Hard Drive, Quick Answer: Question Can I Use My Android Phone As A Universal Remote, Quick Answer: Best Answer Can Windows 10 Run On Intel Pentium, You Asked What Happens If I Reset Bios To Factory Settings, Quick Answer: You Asked How Long Does It Take To Install Ubuntu On Windows 10, How Do You Repair Windows 7 That Will Not Boot, How Do I Change The Font On My Computer Windows 7, Question Is Windows 8 1 Update Still Available, Quick Answer: Will Windows 10 Erase My Files, Frequent Question Is Debian Better Than Ubuntu, Question: Question What Operating System Does This Computer Have, Question How Can I Permanently Activate My Windows For Free, Question: How Do I Test My Microphone On My Headphones Windows 7, Question: How Can I Record My Android Gameplay. What one needs to be happy is love: companionship, friends, and fellowship. He feels that they somehow deserve their plight and he should not be expected to prolong their miserable existence by giving charity. We should figure out ways for the poor to earn more. Your email address will not be published. Analyzes how charles dickens shows the change in scrooges character in a christmas carol, look closely at the language used and how thisinfluences the reader. Opines that scrooge's key moments were when he asked the youngster to buy the largest turkey and send it to bob cratchit. Analyzes how scrooge promises to honor christmas from deep within his heart. they represent the people pf this world that are ignorant and just want more and more. Where people disliked people and wanted them to die, just to get there money. In the first scene, Grudge tells his liberal nephew, played by Ben Gazzara, that he wont give money to Gazzaras college for an exchange with a professor from Poland because he didnt want to support Communism. DOCX Aylesford School, Kent | Courage Confidence Character Above each of the following words, write S for singular or P for plural. The passionate struggle of man should be for love, not wealth. Opines that they are here tonight to warn you that you have a chance and hope of success. Analyzes how dickens uses religion to present scrooge as a non-religion, stating that if he was religious, his behavior would be different. Dickens used 'Christmas Carol' to attack inequality - Futurity Concludes that dickens presents scrooge as an evil, aged, prosperous man in the 1st stave and explains how the cold weather can hurt and be distasteful to people just like him. I will live in the Past, the Present, and the Future. I believe this is how Britain was at the time. They are festive and too cheerful but still very familiar to Scrooge. What trick does Scrooge play on Bob Cratchit? It also shows that The adjective 'surplus' interlinks with the Malthusian economic theory which shows the inchoate mentality people had. Ebenezer Scrooge is the major character in the story, A Christmas Carol written by Charles Dickens. Nov 15, 2015. Although in three nights it could be fixed so life would be normal again. Narrates how scrooge finds himself in a bustling city on christmas morning, where he sees christmas shoppers wishing merry christmas to passersby. Scrooge, said the gentleman, taking up a pen, it is more than usually desirable that we should make some slight provision for the Poor and destitute, who suffer greatly at the present time. Opines that dickens' a christmas carol is set in london in the middle of the 19th century, which is where the problems are occurring. he wrote about poverty as he had experiences this awful incident in his upbringings. He was an old miser and he was malcontent. He may be rich but he lives as though he was poor. Analyzes how the title of the novella 'a christmas carol' suggests that the story will be a joyful christian message. The narrator considers that the phrase "dead as a doornail" doesn't even describe Marley's lifelessness well enough. The visitation is real. This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. Dickens used Scrooge, the main character in the book at first to show how current society was at the time and then at the end, after the visits from the three ghosts, how the society could be. In the final chapter of Dickens story, we are privileged to witness a complete and total alteration of the personal identity in Scrooge that exudes all that is good, all that is beautiful, and all that is true from the depths of his core; revealing a genuine heartfelt conversion. In the beginning of the play in spite of being selfish Scrooge is also cheap, cold-hearted, and cruel. Analyzes present's impact on scrooge: the businessmen in the present talk about him and he doesn't want people to hate him. He used it to dramatize, and give emotive force, to the demand that they be treated with Christian charity, rather than being blamed for their own hardships and left to suffer if they could not support themselves. By spending as little as possible, says Harford, Scrooge was a model of inadvertent benevolenceRegardless of Scrooges motives, because he spent less, everyone else enjoyed more, as surely as if Scrooge had divided his fortune and sent a few coins to everyone in the country.. In each of the following sentences, underline the pronoun in parentheses that agrees with its antecedent. We too have been visited by a Spirit, one who offers not merely a chance and hope but a certain victory over spiritual death. tells them how to behave through the character of Scrooge. Why does Scrooge advocate the death of the poor? Futurity is your source of research news from leading universities. Scrooge and why the transformation occurred. But it is not merely his death, but especially the kind of death that shakes Scrooge: a death un-mourned and even celebrated; a death that reveals the utter emptiness and selfishness of his life. We are learning about this in school in ELA and I just thought you might want to know this :). Why does Scrooge order cab for Camden Town? Very poor but still gives money. he is also disrespectful to bob cratchit, his employee. the spirit takes him to the home of bob crachit where they sit and savor the few christmas treats they can afford. They are the working poor, for, as we know, Bob Cratchit has a steady full-time job as Scrooge's clerk. Analyzes how dickens uses the weather to show that scrooge is a dark person and he made everything around him miserable. eNotes Editorial, 11 May 2019, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/why-did-ghost-christmas-present-show-scrooge-all-1399512. Analyzes how dicken's representation of scrooge in ch.1 of "a christmascarol" contrasts with the image he develops in the final chapter. "If they would rather die," said Scrooge, "they had better do it, and decrease the surplus population." Does he succeed? One way of proving this is when Fred said Merry Christmas. Scrooge replied salty saying Humbug Christmas is just a time for spending and wasting money. Not only he treats Fred badly but many more people. Scrooge has a bad attitude towards the poor, and he seems to feel that their poverty is a choice rather than an unfortunate circumstance. Scrooge knows that poverty is awful, but his fear has made him selfish towards those in need. He takes the delivery man and bird to Camden Town to Bob Cratchit. he knows that christmas day is only once a year and it is festive season. Christ rose from the grave and appeared before them, not as a tormented shade, but as the master of death and the king of life. Analyzes how scrooge is taken by the spirit to a game where the contestants must figure out an answer based on the description provided by fred. However he was greedy and made him hide his old ways. Analyzes how scrooge changes after seeing his grave. Explains that life is like a road where there's signs and ruts, but few ever have the right car or enough gas to get there. Despite A Christmas Carols arch-Englishness, it has lessons for us today regarding the strife and cruelty that have become so prominent in American political culture. You fear the world too much. In the 19th century, poverty was a major problem and was a crucial crisis for those who couldn't support themselves. When a charity worker laments that people would rather die than go to the filthy workhouses, Scrooge replies: Analyzes how charles dickens uses description in 'a christmas carol' to help get across some of his ideas. 123Helpme.com. Explains that the theme of the novella is to look at the good you do in life and how it carries over after your death. Analyzes how the repetitive, rhythmic hard consonant sounds portray scrooge and how his actions and behaviour effects people around him. Describes how nick's life was in a rut and he decided to change his routine and walk the road of life. ", Analyzes how scrooge refuses to share his nephew's christmas cheer. What the Ghost actually shows is the Cratchit family celebrating Christmas together. The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come is silent and wears a long, hooded garment. the adjective "surplus" further interlinks with the Malthusian Economic Theory, it shows the inchoate mentality the people of convention had. We all know the point of A Christmas Carolmiserly Scrooge becomes more admirable when he becomes more generous. What is the theme of A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens? "Are there no prisons?" The ghost of Christmas yet to come has the most impact on Scrooge because it makes him fear what has yet to come and makes him want to change in any way possible.